The Victorians had created Highgate Cemetery as a theatre of mourning, a stage set of eternal repose. [From Her Fearful Symmetry by Audrey Niffenegger.]
I recently read and reviewed Audrey Niffeneggar’s novel Her Fearful Symmetry and learned about Highgate Cemetery, in which significant parts of the narrative are set. I had also read Falling Angels by Tracey Chevalier, also set in the Cemetery. So, on the spur of the moment, I made a decision to take the train and then the Underground to Highgate, north of London, to see the Cemetery. In this blog I want to share some of what I saw, partly denoted by text from the novels, from the Cemetery website and from a booklet entitled In Highgate Cemetery, published by The Friends of Highgate Cemetery and sold on site. The Friends of Highgate Cemetery (FOHC) are a charitable group now caring for the Cemetery.
“Not even the Queen may go around unaccompanied,” the chair of the Friends is quoted as saying.
Highgate Cemetery is not open to the public except for subscribed tours and I was not certain I could even get to take one, and that the cemetery would be closed to me otherwise because I do not have family buried there. The week-day tours were booked ten days in advance, but I had noticed that Saturday tours were on a first-come-first-served basis. I arrived 30 minutes before the first tour, and lucked into finding that one of the volunteer guides, Neil, had come to the cemetery early, and offered to let the eight of us in the queue get a head start with a much smaller group than usual.
Two Tudor style mortuary chapels were built when the cemetery opened, topped with wooden turrets and a central bell tower. It is quite unusual for an Anglican Chapel to be connected to a Dissenters’ Chapel. (The Non-Conformist chapel was used when the deceased was not a member of the Church of England.)
-From Her Fearful Symmetry:
The unparalleled elevation overlooking London, with its highest point being 375’ above sea level, along with unique architecture, meant that the wealthy were encouraged to invest.
Although some wealthy families continued to purchase rights of burial during the 1930s, Highgate Cemetery was passing into a long, slow, terminal decline. Greater and greater numbers of graves became abandoned and maintenance became minimal. The chapels were closed in 1956. In 1960 the London Cemetery Company, facing bankruptcy, was absorbed into the larger United Cemetery Company, which struggled to keep the cemetery afloat until funds ran out in 1975.
-From Her Fearful Symmetry:
“In 1975 the Western side was padlocked and essentially abandoned to Satanists, nutters, vandals, Johnny Rotten—“
“Who’s he?” one of the young Japanese men wanted to know.
The other author associated with Highgate is the American novelist Tracey Chevalier, who set her novel Falling Angels in the historical period just after the death of Queen Victoria. According to a writer for the Sunday Times, “Before embarking on her novel, determined to get to know the place thoroughly, Chevalier volunteered with the Friends first as a gardener, helping to tame the wilderness that is Highgate’s keynote, and then became a tour guide.”
Many memorials tell you something about the person’s occupation – one of the most famous being that of James Selby (1842-1888), the celebrated coachman. He achieved fame in July 1888 when he did the coach trip to London and Brighton and back in less than eight hours, winning a bet struck earlier that year at Ascot Races (reportedly for an impressive £1000). His memorial records:
This monument was erected to the memory of James W. Selby, the noted whip and proprietor of the Old Times coach, as a mark of esteem by his many coaching friends.
-From Her Fearful Symmetry.
There are about 169,000 persons buried in Highgate, in 52,500 graves, mausoleums, catacombs, etc. This tomb is fascinating. Built by a man for hisentire family, the first burial came very quickly. Her casket was the first to be lowered into the 25-foot deep crypt under the slab. But she is the only one in there. Her husband remarried and raised a large family, but all are buried elsewhere, leaving the first wife alone. (Although, as the guide pointed out, her in-laws are buried opposite her on the other side of the path.)
The Family Tomb of General Sir Loftus Otway. He was a Commander in the Peninsular War.
The guide told us repeatedly that every symbol on a grave carries significance. Note the inverted cannons as chain posts. At one time, the mausoleum ceiling had windows into which visitors could look in on the coffins below. These have been replaced by slabs of stone.
Off the pathway, opposite the grave of Elizabeth Jackson, the first burial in Highgate, in 1839, is the Pyramid, called in the old days The Sugar Loaf. Many of the symbols, even in the High Anglican Section, have pagan origins, such as the Egyptian pyramid.
Many of the newer tombstones are a far cry from the Victorian taste, such as this stone for the artist Nicki Price, who died in 2009.
The Egyptian Avenue
In the very heart of the grounds was created the grandest and most eccentric structure, an avenue of vaults on either side of a passageway entered through a great arch. It was created in the Egyptian style which was so in vogue following the discovery of the Valley of the Kings. The pathway is variously called The Avenue of Death or Street of the Dead.
-From Her Fearful Symmetry. Robert is giving a tour of the cemetery:
Robert loved the drama of the Egyptian Avenue; it looked like a stage set for Aida.
“Highgate Cemetery, in addition to being a Christian Burial ground, was a business venture. In order to make it the most desirable address for the eminent Victorian dead, it needed what every posh neighbourhood needs: amenities. In the late 1830s, when Highgate opened, all things Egyptian were quite popular, and so we have here the Egyptian Avenue. The entrance is based on a tomb at Luxor. It was originally coloured, and the Avenue itself was not so dark and gloomy. It was open to the sky, and there were none of the trees that lean over it now . . .”
These vaults were fitted with shelves for 12 coffins. According to our guide, the Egyptian Avenue was first mocked as a feature in a Christian cemetery, but after Queen Victoria approved of Cleopatra’s Needle on the Embankment on the Thames, the vaults became sought-after burial locations.
“Of course, people still had to be buried. Cemeteries like Highgate had plenty of funerals. But people spent less on them, and on the monuments—which were usually bought at the mason’s yard run by the cemetery. With less income, staff had to be laid off, and the others were concentrated on the business of burying. Trees and ivy slowly strangled the prized landscape design; burrowing roots toppled monuments. All this took time, but those cemeteries, once boastful displays of wealth and status, are now overgrown stone junkyards, with the odd jewel shining through the ivy.” (Tracey Chevalier, website for Falling Angels.)
The avenue led into the Circle of Lebanon, built in the same style. This circle was created by earth being excavated around an ancient Cedar of Lebanon, a legacy of the Ashurst Estate and used to great effect by the cemetery’s designers. The Cedar is probably 300 years old, but according to our guide, the excavation of the Circle cut off the tree’s roots, and that that stunted its growth, leaving it as a sort of bonsai tree.
-From Her Fearful Symmetry. Robert continues his tour spiel:
A scene from the 2009 film Dorian Grey was filmed on this stairwell at the Lebanon Circle.
-From Her Fearful Symmetry:
IN THE MEMORY of George Wombwell (Menagerist) 1777-1850, and his favourite lion, Nero. The lion was originally pure white marble and attracted lots of attention in the cemetery. Wombwell had founded Wombwell’s Travelling Menagerie in 1810, having begun with two boa constrictors, and eventually exhibited elephants, giraffes, a gorilla, kangaroo, leopards, six lions (including Nero), llamas, monkeys, panthers, a rhino, and more. He was invited to exhibit thrice before Queen Victoria. All of this in the days before zoos in Britain.
The Terrace Catacombs are immediately below or behind St. Michael’s Church. (Samuel Taylor Coleridge is buried under the name in St Michael’s.) Built in the Gothic style, the catacombs were completed in 1842 with an impressive 80 yard frontage, with room for a total of 825-840 people. Extensive repair work has taken place and is still ongoing. We went inside to see the dimly lit long passageway, both sides of which are niches called loculi into which coffins were inserted and name panels or stele subsequently added. According to the official booklet, “When light filtered through the glass roundels set into the asphalt roof above, the freshly lime-washed walls once gave a measure of reassuring brightness to the reposeful dignity of this habitation of the dead.” Today it is far from bright, not white-washed for years, but with the help of a large flashlight, the guide was able to show us part of the catacombs. In several cases we were able to look closely at the ends of perfectly intact caskets, still showing the original brassware. Part of the passageway was blocked because a part of the catacombs had collapsed at some time, and the guide said the caskets were crushed and bones were visible. To preserve dignity we were not shown this section, nor were we allowed to take any photos. It seems the current restoration will make possible the use of the catacombs again, as there are over 100 unused loculi.
“That blasted cemetery. I never liked it. To be fair, it is not the fault of the place itself, which has a lugubrious charm, with its banks of graves stacked on top of one another—granite headstones, Egyptian obelisks, gothic spires, plinths topped with columns, weeping ladies, angels, and, of course, urns—winding up the hill to the glorious Lebanon Cedar at the top. I am even willing to overlook some of the more preposterous monuments—ostentatious representations of a family’s status. But the sentiments that the place encourages in mourners are too overblown for my taste.” (Kitty Coleman, in Falling Angels.)
-From Her Fearful Symmetry:
The mausoleum of Julius Beer is the largest and most expensive one in Highgate, built by Italian craftsmen for £5,000 in 1878, £1-£2 million today. Although not normally open to visitors, our small group was allowed to look inside. It is a beautiful work of art. The interior is in the Quattrocento style with an exquisite mosaic ceiling, colourful wall tiles, and stained glass windows to let in the light. The ceiling is decorated in gold leaf. The main feature is a beautiful bas-relief sculpture of his daughter Ada, carved by H. H. Armstead, showing a marble angel stooping to kiss eight-year-old Ada. The face of the sculpture is based on the death mask of the child. Julius Beer died in 1880 at age 43, never having seen the carving of his daughter, The family is buried in a vault underneath the building.
Julius Beer was a Jew from Frankfurt born into poverty, but he made his fortune on the London Stock Exchange and owned The Observer newspaper. However, being foreign and Jewish and having earned his wealth, he always felt ostracized by Victorian society. Beer’s revenge was to situate this magnificent mausoleum in a location that blocked the view over London from the promenade above, where the upper class like to stroll and have picnics on Sundays. However, being Jewish, he was not qualified for burial in a High Anglican cemetery, but one source says he converted to the Church of England in the 1880s.
-From Her Fearful Symmetry. Robert is showing the most impressive mausoleum in the cemetery:
“Our Granpa worked here too. Same as our Pa and me. Said it’s the nicest cemetery in London. Wouldn’t have wanted to be buried in any of t’others. He had stories to tell us about t’others. Piles of bones everywhere. Bodies buried with just a sack of soil over ‘em. Phew, the smell! And the men snatching bodies in the night. Here he were safe at least safe and sound, with the boundary wall being so high, and the spikes on top.” (Simon Field, the gravedigger’s son in Falling Angels.)
The grave of Edgar Hodges Baily, (1788-1867) from Bristol. Not only did he sculpt the statue of Horatio Nelson atop the column in Trafalgar Square, he also created many other works, including bas reliefs on the Marble Arch. Baily studied at the Royal Academy and was a member of the Royal Society. The grave features an open Bible.
Norman Warne published the highly successful The Tale of Peter Rabbit, by Beatrix Potter. Around that time she became secretly engaged to him, which caused problems with her parents, who believed such a marriage would be beneath her station, since he was of a lower social class. Warne died before the wedding could take place. Our guide told us that there are records that say that Miss Potter used to come and visit her fiancĂ©’s grave. Apparently, the recent film about Beatrix Potter has the actor stand here and point out Norman Warne’s tombstone.
Joseph Hodgson, President of the College of Physicians, died at age 80, one day after his wife passed away.
The sleeping angel on the grave is considered by many to be the most beautifully sculpted angel in Highgate. (This is not my photo: at this very moment my camera announced a full memory card. I tried to erase old photos as we walked, but ended up taking fewer photos on my camera’s built-in memory.)
"In Ever Loving Memory of Mary, the darling wife of Arthur Nichols. Kindly loved mother of their only son Harold, who fell asleep 7th May 1909."
In Memory of Mrs. Ann Webb (widow of William Webb, Esq.) Who revered and beloved by her children of three generations departed this life in the sure hope of salvation through Christ August 1st 1849 in the 102nd year of her age.
Quite remarkable, considering that the average age of those buried here is about 40!
-From Her Fearful Symmetry.
I have only a couple of regrets about my visit to Highgate. The tour does not include a visit to the Rossetti graves. I am a huge “fan” of the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood. Dante Gabrielle Rossetti is not buried here but in Birchington-on-Sea in Kent, where he died at 53. Buried in Highgate are his father, brother and sister. His wife, Elizabeth, is buried here. She was his model, the beautiful Elizabeth Siddall (about whom I wrote after I visited the Tate Britain and saw Milais’s painting entitled “Ophelia.”) She died of an over-dose of laudanum. Rossetti buried most of his poems with her but later had the grave opened to retrieve the poetry.
There are several quite spectacular monuments I wish I could have seen, but they are not on the tour. I have seen images of them (including that of the Victorian pugilist Thomas Sayers and his dog copied above) and would have enjoyed seeing the Thornton piano—a grand piano in stone—and the Myth of Sisyphus stone.
After the cemetery fell into near ruin in the 1960s, The Friends of Highgate Cemetery was launched to secure access to the cemetery for public benefit and future generations. Over the last 30 years much restoration and conservation work has been carried out on buildings, boundary walls, architectural features and the landscape. Several features and monuments have been listed as of special importance by English Heritage. Extensive work has been carried out on the chapels, which lay derelict until 1985.
-From Her Fearful Symmetry.
George Williams founded the YMCA—The Young Men’s Christian Association (YMCA)—in 1844. Williams was looking for positive alternatives for young men like himself drawn to the temptations of London, and created the YMCA to foster Christian principles in action, achieved by the development of a “healthy spirit, mind and body.” It was at this point that out guide broke into the Village People spelling out Y-M-C-A. My own father was very involved in the YMCA in Halifax, NS, in the 1920s and 30s, mostly, I suspect, for the athletic facilities and opportunities.
Another sculpted tomb, that of the artist and sculptor Michael Kenny R.A., who died in 1999.
John Alfred Groom founded the Orphanage at Clacton-on-Sea and the Crippleage at Clerkenwell. “A servant of God and a friend of the poor, the orphan, and the afflicted.”
Sir Ralph David Richardson’s grave, with members of his family. With John Gielgud and Laurence Olivier, he is considered the third of the great actor Knights of the 20th century.
The wonderful tombstone for Jeremy Beadle MBE, writer, presenter, and curator of oddities, who died in 2008. The message on the stone is basic: “Ask My Friends.”
Anna Mahler (1904-1988) a Viennese sculptor, daughter of composer Gustav Mahler. The memorial is called “Vision” and is a copy of an original now owned by her daughter.
The grave of the Victorian writer, George Eliot, the pen-name of Mary Ann Evans (who later became Mary Ann Cross.) Eliot was the author of several novels well-known to students the world over: The Mill on the Floss (1860), Silas Marner (1861), and Middlemarch (1871-1872). She lived with a married man for over 20 years, causing scandal. She lost her religious faith and this denial of Christianity and her affair with George Henry Lewes prevented her being buried in Westminster Abbey. Thus she is buried here with like-minded free-thinkers amongst atheists and communists.
The ashes of the philosopher and socialist Herbert Spencer (1820-1903) are here. He coined the phrase “survival of the fittest” as a succinct summary of Darwin’s theory.
Arguably the world’s most influential political philosopher, Karl Marx has been called Britain’s most famous refugee. Marx was originally buried in a secluded spot about 200 metres behind his current grave—and only a dozen people even attended his funeral in 1883. But so many visitors were coming to his grave by 1956 that the remains of all those buried in the original spot were moved to this location.
The tablet refers to Jenny Von Westphalen, Marx’s wife; Marx himself; their grandson, Harry Longuet (1875-1883); Helena Demuth (1823-1890); and Marx’s daughter, Eleanor, the political activist and feminist, who committed suicide. (Her ashes were kept elsewhere for 60 years and interred here in 1956.
The new memorial was sculpted by Laurence Bradshaw and dates from then but the tablet is the original.
The philosophers have only interpreted the world in various ways. The point however is to change it.
The largest crowd in the public East Cemetery is always for Karl Marx. This part of Highgate is clearly non-denominational, with burials here of people of all and no faiths. Avowed atheists like Ernestine Rose, the Polish-born feminist who played a major role in the feminist movement in the USA and the UK, and the “fearless and notorious atheist,” George Jacob Holyoake (1817-1878), are buried in what is a dissenter’s section, alongside famous communists like Dr. Yusuf Mohammed Dadoo (1909-1983), the Muslim Indian activist buried just a few feet away from Marx, and Monsoor Hekmat, the Tehran-born humanitarian Marxist theorist and leader of the Iran Worker Communist Party, opponent of the Shah and the Islamic Republic. Forced into exile, he died in 2002.
WORKERS of the ALL LANDS UNITE. Apparently, people care enough about Marx that there are flowers on the grave. Everyone in the crowd—few of whom spoke English—had their photo taken here, so I joined in.
Highgate was not about the tours, or the monuments, not about the supernatural or the atmosphere or the morbid peculiarities of the Victorians; for her, the cemetery was about the dead and the grave owners. [From Her Fearful Symmetry by Audrey Niffenegger.]